Overview
Title
To amend section 102(a)(20) of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 to require the exclusion of service-connected disability compensation when determining whether a person is a person of low and moderate income, a person of low income, or a person of moderate income, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 224 wants to make sure that when the government checks if a veteran needs help paying for a home, it ignores the money veterans get for being hurt while serving. This way, veterans don't miss out on housing help because of their disability money.
Summary AI
H.R. 224, also known as the "Disabled Veterans Housing Support Act," proposes an amendment to the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974. The bill seeks to ensure that service-connected disability compensation from the Department of Veterans Affairs is excluded when evaluating if a person qualifies as low or moderate income for housing support. This change aims to prevent veterans' disability compensation from negatively impacting their eligibility for housing programs. Additionally, the bill requires the Comptroller General to examine and report on how these compensations are considered in various housing programs and suggests improvements for better serving veteran populations.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation titled the "Disabled Veterans Housing Support Act" seeks to amend the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974. Specifically, it aims to change how income is calculated for determining eligibility for low and moderate-income housing programs. The bill proposes excluding service-connected disability compensation received by veterans from being counted as part of their income for these purposes. The Act also mandates a report from the Comptroller General of the United States, analyzing the current treatment of such compensation in housing programs and suggesting improvements to better serve veterans and underserved communities.
Significant Issues
One major issue with the bill is the lack of clarity around its implementation. The language does not specify how the exclusion of service-connected disability compensation will be carried out across various jurisdictions, potentially leading to inconsistent application. Another concern is whether this exclusion should apply uniformly to all recipients of disability compensation or if further criteria will be established. The bill does not mention necessary oversight mechanisms to ensure proper application of the exemption, possibly leading to future implementation and legal challenges.
Additionally, there are questions about the bill's impact on the allocation of benefits to other individuals who do not receive this type of compensation. The reporting requirement included in the bill seems to be ambitious, given the one-year timeframe could be insufficient for a comprehensive examination due to the complexity of the programs involved. There are also terminological ambiguities, such as the failure to define "service-connected disability compensation" formally, which might lead to misinterpretations.
Impact on the Public
Broadly, the bill could have significant implications for both veterans and the general population. For veterans, particularly those receiving service-connected disability compensation, the bill could improve access to housing programs by excluding this compensation from income considerations. This change could enable more veterans to qualify for benefits they might otherwise be ineligible for under current regulations.
On the public front, however, the reallocation of housing resources and benefits might affect others who are not receiving similar compensation, potentially raising concerns about fairness and resource distribution. Local governments and housing authorities might face challenges adapting to these changes without clear guidelines, potentially delaying the support provided to eligible beneficiaries.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Veterans stand to benefit significantly if the bill achieves its objectives. By excluding disability compensation from income calculations, more veterans might gain access to housing assistance, thereby potentially improving their quality of life. On the flip side, these changes could lead to reduced resources for non-veterans who rely on the same programs, particularly if the overall funding levels remain constant.
State and local housing authorities, along with Indian tribes, might face difficulties in implementing these new rules given the current lack of clarity in the bill. Ensuring consistent application across diverse jurisdictions will likely require additional effort and resources.
The bill’s impact on lawmakers and policymakers could also be substantial, as it necessitates changes to existing laws and possibly state-level legislation to ensure uniform application. Moreover, the legislative recommendations from the proposed report might influence future legislative actions aimed at improving housing programs for veterans and underserved communities.
Issues
The amendment in Section 2 lacks clarity on the implementation across different states and local governments, which may lead to inconsistent applications that could affect the benefits of veterans and service members, having significant political and legal implications.
Section 2 does not specify whether the exclusion of service-connected disability compensation applies uniformly to all individuals or if there are additional criteria, which may create confusion and inequity in the application of the bill.
The absence of oversight or reporting mechanisms in Section 2 to ensure that the exclusion is correctly applied could lead to implementation challenges and potentially result in legal disputes.
The amendment's impact on the allocation of benefits or services to other individuals not receiving service-connected disability compensation is unclear, potentially leading to financial and social issues due to resource distribution imbalances.
Section 3's reporting timeframe of 1 year may not be sufficient to adequately assess the complex interplay of various HUD programs with the amendment, which could result in incomplete reporting and legislative oversight.
The use of the term 'service-connected disability compensation' without a formal definition in Section 3 could lead to misunderstandings or interpretation issues, affecting the consistent application of the bill.
The vagueness in Section 3 regarding what constitutes 'better serving veteran populations and under-served communities' could result in subjective interpretations and ineffective policy recommendations.
The term 'legislative recommendations' in Section 3 is vague, creating uncertainty about whether proposals should aim at new legislation, amendments to existing laws, or administrative reforms.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section states that the Act can be referred to as the “Disabled Veterans Housing Support Act.”
2. Service connected disability compensation Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section of the Housing and Community Development Act, it is stated that when deciding if someone qualifies as having low or moderate income, any service-connected disability compensation they receive from the Department of Veterans Affairs should not be counted.
3. Report Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Comptroller General is required to deliver a report to Congress within one year, analyzing how service-related disability compensation is regarded for housing program eligibility, identifying inconsistencies with a specific amendment, and suggesting legislative changes to improve support for veterans and underserved communities.