Overview
Title
To direct the Comptroller General of the United States to report on the H–2A program.
ELI5 AI
H. R. 2237 is a plan where a special helper will write a report about a job program called H-2A that helps farms find extra workers. The report will talk about how this affects people looking for jobs, where the workers live, and if they get paid enough.
Summary AI
H. R. 2237, titled the “Farm Workforce Support Act of 2025,” requires the Comptroller General of the United States to prepare a report on the H–2A temporary visa program within two years of the Act's enactment. The report must analyze the program's effects on hiring, both for domestic and guest workers, the challenges of providing adequate housing for guest workers, and the impact of wage requirements on domestic recruitment efforts. It will also assess the economic effects on the families of guest workers and ensure compliance with employment conditions under the H–2A program. The findings will be submitted to specific Congressional committees focused on education, agriculture, labor, and workforce issues.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The bill, titled the "Farm Workforce Support Act of 2025," is designed to initiate an investigative report regarding the H-2A temporary visa program. This program allows U.S. employers to bring foreign nationals to the United States to fill temporary agricultural jobs. Specifically, the bill mandates the Comptroller General of the United States to produce a comprehensive report on various facets of the H-2A program within two years of the bill's enactment. The report is to be submitted to specified Congressional committees and will investigate the program's impact on hiring, housing, wage requirements, economic effects on guest workers' families, and compliance with working conditions.
Summary of Significant Issues
Several potential issues arise from this bill:
Lack of Initial Start Date: The bill outlines a deadline for the final report but does not specify when work on the report should begin. This absence could lead to delays and affect the timeliness and relevance of any policy recommendations.
Complex Socio-Economic Analysis: The required analyses, such as the economic effect of lost wages from family members of guest workers, demand specific expertise and resources that the bill does not explicitly provide for, potentially compromising the quality of findings.
Subjective Language: Terms like "adequate, affordable housing" are open to interpretation, which could lead to inconsistencies and varied recommendations concerning housing for guest workers.
Measurement Challenge: The bill does not define how to gauge "increasing reliance" on the program by American employers, introducing the risk of subjective findings that could affect program evaluation.
Lack of Definite Consequences: There are no stipulated actions following the report's results, which might limit the effect of any critical findings on the H-2A program.
Assumed Familiarity with Immigration Law: By presuming that readers are familiar with the Immigration and Nationality Act, the bill could be less accessible to stakeholders who lack such expertise.
Impact on the Public Broadly
For the general public, this bill’s implications revolve around how effectively the H-2A program supports the agricultural workforce and balances it with domestic employment opportunities. Insights into whether American employers overly depend on foreign labor over domestic workers could influence public and legislative opinions on immigration and labor policies. The report could instigate further discussions about immigrant labor rights, domestic workforce priorities, and the adequacy of the current regulatory framework concerning agricultural labor.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
American Employers: Farmers and agricultural businesses dependent on the H-2A program might be directly affected by this legislation. Depending on the report’s findings and any subsequent legislative action, they may experience changes in program accessibility, wage requirements, or housing obligations for guest workers.
Guest Workers: For non-U.S. citizens coming to America under the H-2A program, the bill could lead to improved living and working conditions if the report highlights significant issues needing rectification.
Domestic Workers: If the report finds that American workers are negatively impacted by the H-2A program, future legislative adjustments might encourage employing domestic workers more robustly in the agricultural sector.
Policy Makers and Legislators: The report could provide valuable data for making informed decisions about labor laws and immigration policies, potentially driving significant changes within these domains.
In conclusion, while the bill aims to evaluate and potentially improve the H-2A program, its success will depend significantly on how well it addresses the outlined issues and implements actionable findings. The complexity and impact of this report are considerable, and resolving its challenges will be key to achieving its intended objectives.
Issues
The report required by Section 2 does not include a specific deadline for when the Comptroller General must begin the work, potentially causing delays in the report's initiation and affecting timely policy responses.
Section 2 involves complex socio-economic analysis, including the impact of lost wages from a guest worker's family, which may require resources or expertise not specified in the bill, possibly leading to incomplete or skewed findings.
The term 'adequate, affordable housing' in Section 2 is subjective, leading to potential inconsistencies in the report's outcomes, which may impact policy recommendations.
Section 2 lacks a clear definition on how to measure 'increasing reliance' on the H-2A program by American employers, increasing the risk of subjective interpretations and varied conclusions in the report.
There are no specified consequences in Section 2 for identified issues within the H-2A program, diminishing the potential impact of the report on current policies.
The text of Section 2 assumes familiarity with the Immigration and Nationality Act without providing sufficient context or definitions, possibly limiting comprehension by stakeholders less versed in immigration law.
The complexity of analyzing wage rate requirements and recruitment impacts in Section 2 involves numerous variables not outlined in the section, which could complicate achieving accurate and actionable findings.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that it will be called the "Farm Workforce Support Act of 2025".
2. Report on H–2A temporary visa program Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section requires the Comptroller General to deliver a report to specific Congressional committees within two years, examining various aspects and impacts of the H–2A temporary visa program, including its effects on job hiring, housing for guest workers, wage requirements, economic impacts, and compliance with working conditions. It also defines terms like "American employer," "domestic worker," and "guest worker" to clarify the scope of the report.