Overview
Title
To reduce the annual rate of pay of Members of Congress if the public debt limit is reached or a Government shutdown occurs during a year, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
If the government runs out of money or shuts down, this bill says that Congress members won't get paid for those days, but their money is saved up to give back to them later.
Summary AI
H. R. 1973, titled the "No Pay for Congress During Default or Shutdown Act," aims to reduce the annual pay of Members of Congress if the U.S. reaches its public debt limit or if there is a government shutdown. The bill instructs that for each day the debt limit is reached or a shutdown occurs, a day's worth of pay will be deducted from Members' salaries. Additionally, during the 119th Congress, any withheld salaries would be held in an escrow account and paid out at the end of the Congress to comply with constitutional requirements. The Secretary of the Treasury is tasked with assisting Congress in implementing these measures.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, known as the “No Pay for Congress During Default or Shutdown Act,” seeks to reduce the annual pay of U.S. Congress members if the federal public debt limit is reached or if a government shutdown occurs. Under this bill, if such events happen, members' salaries are reduced proportionately each day that the debt limit is reached or the shutdown is in effect. During the specific tenure of the 119th Congress, any withheld salaries are set to be held in an escrow account and released at the conclusion of the Congress. This is designed to comply with constitutional pay rules. The bill delegates responsibility for implementation to Congressional payroll administrators with assistance from the Secretary of the Treasury.
Summary of Significant Issues
A range of issues accompanies the introduction of this bill:
Delayed Application: Importantly, the financial measures proposed would only apply from November 2026, raising questions about the effectiveness of the bill to address financial accountability in the immediate term.
Ambiguity in Definitions: The criteria defining when the public debt limit is considered "reached" or what constitutes a "Government shutdown" are vague and could lead to broad interpretation or potential legal challenges.
Potential Conflict with Constitutional Amendments: The use of escrow accounts to hold Congress members' salaries, with funds released at the end of the Congress, may conflict with the twenty-seventh amendment, which prevents changes to congressional compensation during their term. This poses the risk of judicial scrutiny and potential legal challenges.
Administrative and Operational Concerns: The practical implementation, including the calculation and enforcement of reduced pay, administrative burdens involved in managing escrow accounts, and the role of the Secretary of the Treasury, requires clearer guidance.
Impact on the Public and Specific Stakeholders
Public Impact
From a public perspective, this bill aims to hold Congress accountable by directly linking their compensation to their legislative responsibilities. In theory, it motivates legislators to prevent government shutdowns and manage the national debt more responsibly.
However, the delayed enactment of financial penalties post-2026 may dilute its intended incentive effect for current challenges. Moreover, the potential inability to define key triggers clearly leaves room for misunderstanding and ineffective application.
Impact on Congress Members
For Congress members, the bill presents both a punitive and motivational measure designed to prompt more stable fiscal governance. However, if the escrow mechanism is perceived merely as a deferred payment rather than an actual reduction, its efficacy as a deterrent could be debated. Possible legal battles over constitutional violations might distract from legislative responsibilities.
Administrative and Treasury Staff
The bill places a significant administrative load on payroll staff and the Treasury, with potential ambiguity in the operation and adherence to legal protocols such as the management of escrow funds, heightening the risk of operational inefficiencies and potential errors.
Conclusion
This bill attempts to instill fiscal responsibility at the level of Congressional compensation. However, various issues regarding its definitions, timeline, and potential constitutional conflicts present hurdles that must be addressed to realize its intended goals effectively. The success of the legislation relies on careful refinement and clear articulation of its mechanisms and timelines, to truly impact government fiscal policies and practices positively.
Issues
The bill only applies to Members of Congress starting after the general election in November 2026, potentially delaying the desired financial accountability for any public debt limit reach or Government shutdown before then (Sections 2 and 3).
The definition of 'public debt limit is reached' is not fully clear, as it only mentions the government being unable to make payments without providing specific criteria or indicators. This ambiguity could pose legal and practical challenges (Section 2).
The withholding and escrow of salaries may conflict with the twenty-seventh amendment, which could result in legal challenges, as releasing the funds at the end of the Congress may be seen as delaying pay rather than reducing it (Sections 2 and 3).
Potential confusion exists regarding the application and interplay of the subsections related to salary withholding and handling, which could complicate implementation for payroll administrators (Sections 2 and 3).
The language regarding reduced pay during a Government shutdown lacks clarity on calculation and enforcement, which might result in inconsistent application (Section 3).
The bill does not address the management of escrow funds if a Member of Congress leaves office before the end of the Congress, raising questions about the handling of those funds (Section 2).
The role of the Secretary of the Treasury lacks specific guidelines or limitations on what constitutes 'necessary assistance,' which could lead to broad interpretation and potential misuse or wasteful spending (Section 4).
The definition of 'Government shutdown' relies on the concept of 'lapse in appropriations,' which is vaguely defined and might lead to differing interpretations, thus requiring more precise language (Section 3).
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The opening section of the bill establishes its title as the “No Pay for Congress During Default or Shutdown Act.”
2. Requiring reduction of pay of Members of Congress if public debt limit is reached Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
If the U.S. public debt limit is reached, members of Congress will have their pay reduced for each day the limit is met, and during the 119th Congress, their salaries will be held in escrow and released at the end of the Congress to comply with constitutional pay rules, but reductions won't apply after the 2026 general election.
3. Requiring reduction of pay of Members of Congress if Government shutdown occurs Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
If a Government shutdown happens, members of Congress will have their pay reduced for each day the shutdown lasts, starting after the 2026 general election. During the 119th Congress, any withheld pay due to a shutdown will be held in escrow and released at the end of the Congress, ensuring it does not violate the Constitution, and will not apply to days after the 2026 election.
4. Role of Secretary of the Treasury Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary of the Treasury is responsible for helping the payroll administrators of Congress with whatever they need to enforce the provisions of this Act.
5. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
In this section of the bill, it defines "Member of Congress" as someone in specified roles according to a 1946 Act, and "payroll administrator" is defined for each House of Congress, stating who handles payroll duties within the House of Representatives and the Senate.