Overview
Title
To amend the National Agricultural Research, Extension, and Teaching Policy Act of 1977 to establish the Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee and the Rural Climate Alliance Network, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The H.R. 1904 bill wants to create special teams to help understand how climate change affects farming and help farmers share ideas to deal with it better. It also wants to make sure these teams work well with other groups to keep farms safe from climate problems.
Summary AI
The H.R. 1904 bill aims to amend a 1977 act to create the Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee and the Rural Climate Alliance Network. The bill seeks to improve the alignment of agricultural climate research with national priorities and address areas like data collection and technology transfer. It also focuses on facilitating exchanges and improvements in the field of climate research and adaptation for rural communities and agricultural producers through a national network. Additionally, the bill outlines roles and activities for the committees and networks, including coordination with various agencies to enhance climate change resilience for agriculture.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Overview of the Bill
H.R. 1904, titled the "Improving Coordination of Agriculture Research and Data Act," proposes amendments to the National Agricultural Research, Extension, and Teaching Policy Act of 1977. The main objective is to establish the Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee and the Rural Climate Alliance Network. These entities aim to strategically align agricultural climate research with data systems, strengthen technical support, and set a national research agenda to address climate change impacts on agriculture.
Significant Issues and Analysis
A notable concern is the potential bureaucratic complexity stemming from the creation of the Agriculture Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee. With an 18-member committee comprising high-ranking officials, there's a risk that new layers of administration could introduce inefficiencies without clear success metrics. This committee is tasked with advising the Department of Agriculture on climate-related research priorities, but its extensive reach and the inclusion of multiple officials may lead to overlapping responsibilities with existing bodies.
The section describing the Rural Climate Alliance Network raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest. By including various external entities, such as nonprofits and private businesses, the bill might face challenges in resource allocation and managing different interests. Furthermore, the lack of detailed roles and responsibilities for these entities could lead to confusion and inefficiencies in achieving the Network's objectives.
Potential Public Impact
Broadly, this bill could have significant implications for the U.S. agricultural sector if effectively implemented. Coordinated research and data-sharing efforts can lead to more informed strategies for mitigating and adapting to climate change impacts. This benefit extends to improved food security and sustainable agricultural practices in the face of environmental challenges.
However, the anticipated additional layers of bureaucracy and potential inefficiencies could hinder timely progress. The ability to successfully navigate the complex interactions between different committees and networks will greatly influence the bill's overall impact.
Impacts on Specific Stakeholders
For government agencies and officials, the bill promises a structured approach to climate-related agricultural research, albeit with potential administrative complexities. Some stakeholders might perceive the advisory committee memberships and subsequent decision-making processes as subject to favoritism, especially given the Secretary of Agriculture's significant influence in appointments and decision-making.
For agricultural producers, especially those in rural areas, the Rural Climate Alliance Network could serve as an invaluable resource for adapting their practices to meet climate change challenges. Yet, the success of this initiative will largely depend on a clear framework of accountability and transparency in managing the network's activities, ensuring that producers' perspectives and needs are prioritized effectively.
In conclusion, while the bill addresses critical issues in agricultural research and climate change adaptation, its success hinges on careful implementation, avoidance of redundancies, and maintaining transparent and equitable processes. By addressing these challenges, the proposed changes hold potential for positive advancements in sustainable agriculture and climate resilience.
Issues
The creation of the Agriculture Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee in Section 3 could add new bureaucratic layers, potentially leading to inefficiencies and increased administrative costs without clear success metrics.
Section 3 also introduces the Rural Climate Alliance Network, which could lead to conflict of interest issues or resource allocation challenges due to the inclusion of numerous external entities, such as nonprofits and private businesses.
The compensation structure for the committee staff in Section 3 is not clearly defined, which could lead to excessive spending if not properly managed. Furthermore, members serve without pay, potentially hindering participation by qualified candidates who cannot afford to work without compensation.
The broadly stated purposes in Section 2 might lack specific details regarding the strategic alignment of agriculture climate research and data systems, leading to challenges in implementation and accountability.
Legal references to other sections of the U.S. Code and external acts in Sections 3 and 1419 make the text difficult to parse for those unfamiliar with legal documents, reducing accessibility for general stakeholders.
The potential for committee members to serve for up to 12 years, as stated in Section 1413C, may discourage turnover and the influx of fresh ideas, which could lead to stagnation and bias towards established interests.
The provision in Section 3 allowing the Secretary significant involvement could centralize decision-making, potentially overlooking valuable insights from other committee members and reducing the breadth of perspectives considered.
The report to Congress provision in Section 1419 lacks specific deadlines for subsequent reports after the initial one-year report, which could impact long-term oversight and accountability.
There are no details on potential funding sources or budget allocations in Section 2, which could lead to concerns about financial transparency or accountability and impact the feasibility of the proposed initiatives.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the Act provides its official title, which is the "Improving Coordination of Agriculture Research and Data Act".
2. Purposes Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The purposes of this Act are to better organize agricultural climate research and data, enhance the sharing of technical knowledge and technologies, and develop a national plan for agricultural research to address climate change.
3. Agriculture climate research coordination and data Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The document outlines the creation of an Agriculture Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee, which will guide the Department of Agriculture's climate research and policy efforts, identifying research gaps and consulting with various organizations. Additionally, it establishes a Rural Climate Alliance Network to coordinate climate data and technology transfer to improve climate change resilience in agricultural and rural communities.
1413C. Agriculture Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Agriculture Climate Scientific Research Advisory Committee is established by the Secretary to advise and make recommendations on US Department of Agriculture policies and priorities related to climate-specific agricultural research and environmental outcomes. This 18-member committee, which includes various officials and appointed experts, reviews national research agendas and collaborates with industry and government entities, while members volunteer without pay, except for travel expenses.
1419. Rural Climate Alliance Network Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Rural Climate Alliance Network is a proposed initiative by the Secretary of Agriculture to create a network focused on providing climate change-related research and technical assistance to agricultural producers and communities. This network will involve various entities such as universities, government agencies, and nonprofits to help improve climate adaptation and mitigation efforts in agriculture by facilitating data sharing, technology transfer, and training.