Overview
Title
An Act To authorize the National Medal of Honor Museum Foundation to establish a commemorative work on the National Mall to honor the extraordinary acts of valor, selfless service, and sacrifice displayed by Medal of Honor recipients.
ELI5 AI
The bill allows a group to build a special monument on the National Mall in Washington, D.C., to honor people who have been really brave and received the Medal of Honor.
Summary AI
H.R. 186 seeks to allow the National Medal of Honor Museum Foundation to build a commemorative monument on the National Mall. The monument will honor the bravery and sacrifices of Medal of Honor recipients. It will be located near the Lincoln Memorial as a tribute to both Abraham Lincoln and the heroic actions of these individuals. The bill ensures that the monument aligns with existing laws governing commemorative works.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The proposed bill, House Resolution 186, seeks to authorize the National Medal of Honor Museum Foundation to establish a commemorative monument on the National Mall. This effort is dedicated to honoring Medal of Honor recipients' extraordinary valor, selflessness, and sacrifice. The Medal of Honor, a prestigious military decoration awarded for heroism in combat, holds historical significance dating back to its establishment by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863. The bill emphasizes the monument’s proximity to the Lincoln Memorial as a symbolic extension of Lincoln's legacy, celebrating ordinary individuals who have demonstrated exceptional bravery.
General Summary of the Bill
HR 186, also known as the “Hershel ‘Woody’ Williams National Medal of Honor Monument Location Act,” aims to locate a commemorative work on the National Mall, specifically within an area known as the Reserve. This monument would serve as a testament to the valor and heroism of Medal of Honor recipients from all branches of the U.S. Armed Forces. In doing so, the bill acknowledges the calculated decline in the number of living recipients and underscores the importance of preserving and promoting these narratives for future generations.
Summary of Significant Issues
A few significant issues arise from the bill’s provisions:
Location Ambiguity: The bill outlines the intended monument location within the Reserve but lacks precise details about the specific site, which could lead to future disputes about its placement.
Bypassing Site Evaluation: An exception to the usual site evaluation processes may result in preferential or biased decisions regarding the monument's location, raising concerns about transparency and fairness.
Financial Transparency: The bill does not clearly address the estimated costs or funding sources for the monument, posing uncertainties around financial management and accountability.
Complex Legal References: The text contains numerous cross-references to existing legal texts, making it challenging to comprehend its implications without a solid understanding of those references.
Impact on the Public
This bill could influence the general public by creating a national monument that commemorates and immortalizes acts of valor, promoting patriotism and informed appreciation of military service. It has the potential to educate and inspire visitors to the National Mall by showcasing human capacity for bravery and selflessness, encouraging citizens to aspire to these ideals.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Positive Impacts:
Medal of Honor Recipients and Families: The monument would provide recognition and honor for the recipients and their families, affirming their sacrifices' value and significance.
Historical and Educational Institutions: The establishment of the monument offers new opportunities for collaborations in education and historical research about military valor and history.
Potential Negative Impacts:
Local Community and Planners: Without precise siting and clear processes, planning and executing the monument may pose logistical challenges and create tensions or delays in development.
Advocacy Groups Focused on Open Spaces: Those who prioritize preserving open and natural spaces within urban environments might view the monument's construction as an encroachment, especially if the exact location falls in a highly traveled or environmentally sensitive area.
Overall, while the bill carries the noble intention of commemorating valor, clarity, transparency, and inclusivity in the decision-making processes will be essential to garnering widespread support and ensuring that the monument serves as a respectful and enduring tribute.
Issues
The definition of the location for the National Medal of Honor Monument is ambiguous because it does not specify an exact site within the Reserve, potentially leading to disputes or delays in site identification and approval (Section 3).
The exception to section 8908(c) of title 40 in locating the commemorative work might bypass typical site evaluation processes, potentially resulting in preferential location decisions or perceived biases (Section 3).
The act lacks transparency as it does not provide estimated costs or funding sources for the National Medal of Honor Monument, which raises concerns about financial implications and accountability (Section 3).
The language in Section 3 is heavily reliant on cross-references to other legal texts, making it difficult for those not familiar with these references to fully comprehend the implications and legal framework of the monument's location.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the act gives its short title as the “Hershel ‘Woody’ Williams National Medal of Honor Monument Location Act.”
2. Findings Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Congress acknowledges the historical and ongoing significance of the Medal of Honor, which is awarded across all branches of the U.S. Armed Forces for exceptional valor in combat. They emphasize the importance of commemorating these acts through the establishment of a National Medal of Honor Monument near the Lincoln Memorial to honor past and inspire future generations by showcasing ordinary citizens' extraordinary actions.
3. National Medal of Honor Monument Location Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section specifies that the National Medal of Honor Monument will be located within a designated area called the Reserve, as outlined by a particular U.S. law, and states that the regular rules for commemorative works will apply except for the location requirement.