Overview
Title
An Act To amend the South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988, and for other purposes.
ELI5 AI
The bill is about changing the rules for tuna fishing in the South Pacific. It updates who can fish where, what they can't do, and how to report it, but some parts are not very clear, which could cause confusion.
Summary AI
H.R. 1792 aims to amend the South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988. The bill makes multiple changes, including updating definitions related to fishing areas and vessels, outlining prohibited activities, and addressing criminal and civil penalties. It also revises licensing processes and confidentiality guidelines for reporting information. Additionally, the bill provides for technical assistance to Pacific Island Parties, modifies arbitration procedures, and sets the framework for additional fishing access agreements.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
The bill titled "An Act to amend the South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988, and for other purposes" proposes several changes aimed at updating regulations around tuna fishing in the South Pacific. This includes amendments to definitions, prohibited acts, and legal procedures related to fishing licenses, enforcement, and information disclosure.
General Summary of the Bill
The primary aim of the bill is to amend and update the South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988. Key areas of focus include altering definitions to align with new regional agreements, refining prohibited acts related to fishing, and revising the rules for obtaining fishing licenses. It also addresses the rules for reporting requirements, enforcement actions, and technical assistance to Pacific Island Parties in managing their fisheries. The bill passed the House of Representatives in April 2024 and is currently being reviewed by the Senate.
Significant Issues
One of the major issues with the bill is the lack of clarity in several sections. For example, changes in prohibited acts are noted, but the bill does not specify the penalties for new violations, which could lead to difficulties in enforcement. Additionally, the bill lacks details on how confidential information should be managed, potentially leading to inconsistent application and concerns about data privacy.
Another issue arises from the repeal of certain provisions, such as the entire section on observers. The bill does not provide reasons or context for these repeals, which raises questions about the impact on regulatory oversight and transparency. Similarly, the amendments to technical assistance do not specify budget allocations or clear guidelines, leaving room for discretionary spending without proper checks.
Potential Impacts on the Public
Broadly, this bill might impact how fishing activities are regulated in the Pacific region, potentially affecting seafood supply chains and fishing communities. Changes in enforcement rules could also impact how swiftly laws are applied and whether violations are effectively managed. If not implemented clearly, the public might witness inconsistent regulatory practices, which could affect consumer trust in seafood safety and sustainability.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For specific stakeholders, such as Pacific Island Parties, the amendments could offer more technical and training support for managing fisheries, which might foster economic development in these regions. However, the lack of clear guidelines on what "technical assistance" entails could result in varied implementation outcomes.
Fishing companies and vessel operators might face challenges due to increased regulatory ambiguity or altered licensing requirements. Without clear rules, these stakeholders might incur additional administrative burdens or uncertainties in fishing operations.
Meanwhile, environmental groups may feel concerned about the repeal of observer-related provisions, as onboard observers are crucial in ensuring sustainable fishing practices. The ambiguity around newly defined prohibited acts and confidentiality also raises potential issues related to transparency and accountability in environmental reporting.
In conclusion, while the bill appears to streamline several regulatory aspects of tuna fishing, the lack of transparency and clarity on several key amendments raises valid concerns that may affect public trust and the equitable implementation of the law. Addressing these gaps would be crucial to ensuring that the bill achieves its intended objectives without disproportionately affecting certain groups.
Issues
The language in Section 4 'Prohibited acts' lacks specificity regarding the penalties or implications of newly added prohibitions, which can lead to ambiguity in enforcement and potential legal challenges. Striking substantial parts of previous text without adequate explanation raises concerns about omissions and transparency.
Section 11 'Reporting requirements; disclosure of information' does not provide clear criteria for designating information as 'confidential', potentially leading to inconsistent application and misuse. There is also a lack of explicit oversight mechanisms, raising accountability concerns.
Section 12 'Closed Area stowage requirements' replaces specific stowage instructions with more general directives, leading to potential ambiguity and inconsistent application, complicating compliance and enforcement.
Section 5 'Exceptions' repeals an entire section without providing any context or explanation, which could lead to confusion or a perception of lack of transparency among stakeholders.
Section 14 and Section 15 'Technical assistance' fail to specify a budget or allocation, or define what constitutes 'technical assistance', which can lead to potential wasteful spending and unchecked discretionary allocation.
Section 3 'Definitions' uses technical and legalistic language that may be inaccessible to non-experts, leading to potential misunderstandings, particularly in terms like 'regional terms and conditions' that could give excessive power or ambiguity to the 'Administrator'.
Section 9 'Enforcement' and Section 10 'Findings by Secretary' heavily rely on cross-references to legal sections without providing context, making it challenging to understand and potentially leading to ambiguities if the referenced sections are not reviewed.
Section 13 'Observers' abruptly repeals an entire section without context or rationale, raising concerns about its impact on policies or stakeholders involved in observing activities.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title; table of contents Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The "South Pacific Tuna Treaty Act of 2023" provides a comprehensive framework for matters related to tuna management in the South Pacific, outlining amendments to the South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988, defining various rules and regulations, such as prohibited acts, licenses, and reporting requirements, and detailing enforcement measures and penalties.
2. Amendment of South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988 Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines that any references to changes or removals in this Act are meant to apply to the South Pacific Tuna Act of 1988, unless stated otherwise.
3. Definitions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text outlines changes to a bill regarding definitions related to fishing laws. It updates terminology for applicable national law, closed areas, fishing activities, and fishing vessels, while also introducing the concept of "regional terms and conditions" attached to licenses.
4. Prohibited acts Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill modifies the prohibited acts section by removing certain exceptions, eliminating two paragraphs, and adding new violations, including breaking regional terms or fishing limits. It also restructures the numbering and wording in both general and licensing area regulations to align with these changes.
5. Exceptions Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section explains that Section 6, designated as 16 U.S.C. 973d, will be removed from the law.
6. Criminal offenses Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
Section 6 amends a part of the U.S. Code by updating which paragraphs are referenced in a previous law, changing it from referring to parts "(8), (10), (11), or (12)" to referring to parts "(6), (8), (9), or (10)" of section 5(a).
7. Civil penalties Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section of the bill amends the rules related to civil penalties by changing specific legal references and removing certain conditions for liability. It revises which prohibited acts require referral to the Attorney General and updates the language about areas closed to fishing.
8. Licenses Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section discusses amendments to regulations on vessel license applications for fishing, including allowing the Secretary to decide not to forward applications under certain circumstances, like bankruptcy or lack of insurance. It also updates how license holders can fish for tuna under the law, ensuring compliance with international agreements and conservation measures.
9. Enforcement Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section describes amendments to existing U.S. Code related to notice requirements and search and seizure procedures in legal matters with Pacific Island Parties. It specifies changes to how certain articles and clauses are referenced in section 10 of the code.
10. Findings by Secretary Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section modifies regulations related to jurisdiction and procedures for vessels in waters under the Pacific Island Party's authority. It updates references and strikes out certain terms to refine the legal framework in which vessels must operate, especially when they do not comply with the jurisdiction or are under investigation for treaty infringements.
11. Reporting requirements; disclosure of information Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section outlines the rules about keeping certain types of information confidential and specifies the conditions under which it can be shared. It states that the Secretary must keep information from the Administrator, observers, and others private unless exceptions apply, like a court order, use by federal employees for law enforcement, or with written permission from the person who provided the information.
12. Reporting Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The passage outlines rules about keeping some information secret, specifically information given to or collected by certain officials and observers. It also describes when this information can be shared, such as when ordered by a court, for law enforcement, national security, or fishery management, or if the person who provided the information agrees to the sharing.
12. Closed Area stowage requirements Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The amendment to Section 13 (16 U.S.C. 973k) removes the specific requirement that the boom must be lowered and replaces it with a provision that mandates compliance with any requirements set by the Secretary.
13. Observers Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The text states that Section 14 (16 U.S.C. 973l) is repealed, which means that this specific section of the law is no longer in effect.
14. Technical assistance Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section allows the Secretary and the Secretary of State to offer various types of assistance to Pacific Island countries to help them with their fisheries and fishing operations. This assistance can include technical support, training, helping with private business activities, and other suitable actions.
15. Technical assistance Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary and the Secretary of State can offer help to Pacific Island Parties to support their fisheries and fishing boat operations under the Treaty. This includes providing technical help, training opportunities, assistance with private sector projects, and any other activities they think are suitable.
15. Arbitration Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends a part of the law by removing specific references to where the arbitration is supposed to be located under certain articles, and instead specifies that the location will be determined by the Treaty itself.
16. Disposition of fees, penalties, forfeitures, and other moneys Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The bill changes Section 17 of a law (16 U.S.C. 973o) by removing the phrase "Article 4 of" from its current text.
17. Additional agreements Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section amends existing law by allowing the Secretary the authority to set up procedures for reviewing any new fishing access agreements made under the Treaty.