Overview
Title
To direct the Secretary of Homeland Security to submit a report to Congress on crimes committed by individuals granted parole under the Immigration and Nationality Act.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 1714 is a plan that wants a big boss from the U.S. government to make a list of people from other countries who were let into America and then did bad things, like breaking the law. This list will also say where these people came from and if they might know any bad groups.
Summary AI
H.R. 1714, titled the “Criminal Illegal Alien Report Act,” is a bill introduced in the 119th Congress. It mandates the Secretary of Homeland Security to submit a report to Congress within 60 days of the bill's enactment. This report must detail the number of individuals who, having been granted parole under the Immigration and Nationality Act, have committed crimes in the U.S. The report should also include the nationalities of these individuals and any connections they may have to terrorists or transnational criminal organizations.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
H.R. 1714, also referred to as the “Criminal Illegal Alien Report Act,” aims to require the Secretary of Homeland Security to compile and submit a report to Congress. This report would detail crimes committed by individuals granted parole under the Immigration and Nationality Act, particularly those from countries like Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, and Venezuela. This legislation mandates a comprehensive study and reporting on such individuals’ criminal activities, their nationalities, and any possible connections to terrorist or transnational criminal groups. The report is expected within 60 days following the enactment of this act.
Significant Issues
Several critical issues emerge from the requirements of this bill. Central to these is the lack of a clear definition or categorization of 'crimes'. Without uniform criteria, this could lead to varied interpretations and inconsistent enforcement. Furthermore, the bill does not elaborate on how information will be collected. The lack of methodology could result in data reliability issues.
Privacy is also a major concern as the bill mandates the collection and reporting of nationality information linked to criminal activities. This raises ethical questions and potential privacy breaches. Additionally, there are no structured guidelines for the report, risking inconsistency and reduced utility in legislative decision-making.
The bill does not specify any follow-up actions or periodic updates after the initial report, limiting its potential as a tool for ongoing oversight or reforms.
Impact on the Public
The general public might view this bill as a tool for enhancing national security by ensuring transparency in reporting crimes committed by certain immigrant groups. However, there could be societal implications, such as fostering stereotypes or bias against certain nationalities, which could strain community relations and heighten social tensions.
In terms of data transparency and accountability, the bill presents an opportunity for enhanced governmental oversight. However, without periodic updates or clear methodology, its long-term value could be limited.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
For lawmakers, the bill could serve as an instrument to inform decisions regarding immigration and national security. Yet, the ambiguity surrounding the report's definitions and methodology may hinder its utility in crafting effective policy.
For immigrant communities, especially those from the specified countries, there could be a negative impact. The focus on linking nationality with criminal behavior may perpetuate negative stereotypes and increase discrimination against these groups, affecting their integration and safety.
Privacy advocates may see this act as concerning owing to the potential for privacy intrusions without explicit protections in place. This could incite calls for amendments or additional safeguards to prevent misuse of sensitive information.
In summary, while H.R. 1714 aims to enhance oversight concerning individuals granted parole under the Immigration and Nationality Act, it raises significant issues related to clarity, privacy, and implementation logistics. The potential societal and stakeholder impacts require careful consideration and possibly further refinement of the bill’s provisions.
Issues
The report mandated by Section 2 does not provide a clear definition or categorization of 'crimes' which could lead to disparities in interpretation and application of the law, potentially affecting its fairness and enforcement.
Section 2 lacks detail on the sources or methods for gathering information on criminal activities of parolees, raising concerns about the accuracy and reliability of the data.
Privacy issues are significant in Section 2, as the collection and reporting of nationality information tied to criminal activities could lead to ethical concerns and potential breaches of confidentiality.
The absence of specific guidelines on the structure or required metrics for the report in Section 2 may result in inconsistent reporting and reduce the effectiveness of the document in informing legislative decisions.
Section 2 does not mention follow-up actions or consequences after the report's submission to Congress, which limits its potential impact and scope for addressing the issues identified.
The report's long-term utility is questionable due to Section 2 not specifying any requirement for periodic updates, potentially treating it as a one-time report rather than an ongoing oversight mechanism.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
This section states that the Act will be known as the “Criminal Illegal Alien Report Act.”
2. Report on crimes committed by recipients of parole under the Immigration and Nationality Act Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The Secretary of Homeland Security is required to report to Congress within 60 days about the number of people granted parole under certain immigration processes, including those from Cuba, Haiti, Nicaragua, and Venezuela, who have committed crimes in the U.S. This report will also detail their nationalities and any connections they might have to terrorists or international criminal groups.