Overview
Title
To prohibit the President from revoking Presidential permits relating to cross-border energy facilities.
ELI5 AI
H.R. 1587 is a bill that says the President can't take away special permissions for things like pipelines or power lines that cross into other countries, unless Congress says it's okay.
Summary AI
H.R. 1587 aims to prevent the President of the United States from revoking Presidential permits related to cross-border energy facilities, like pipelines or electric transmission facilities, unless Congress passes a law allowing it. The bill specifies that this restriction applies to permits given by some existing Executive Orders. It also defines important terms, such as "border-crossing facility," "natural gas," and "oil," to clarify what is covered under this bill.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
Summary of the Bill
The proposed legislation, H.R. 1587, titled the "Protecting International Pipelines for Energy Security Act," is designed to restrict the President's authority from revoking Presidential permits related to cross-border energy facilities, such as oil and natural gas pipelines or electric transmission facilities. Essentially, it mandates that any such revocation by the President must be authorized through an Act of Congress. This bill seeks to ensure continuity and security in the energy infrastructure that operates across international boundaries.
Significant Issues
There are several significant issues and areas of concern related to this legislation:
Inflexibility in Urgent Situations: By requiring Congressional authorization for the revocation of Presidential permits, this bill could make it difficult to address immediate or rapidly changing circumstances. This limitation could cause delays when swift action might be necessary to protect national interests or react to global events.
Ambiguity and Legal Challenges: The bill introduces potential ambiguity, particularly regarding what constitutes "authorization by an Act of Congress." This lack of clarity may result in legal disputes over the interpretation and enforcement of the law.
References to Executive Orders: The bill references numerous Executive Orders without providing detailed summaries, making it challenging for legislators and the public to grasp the full scope and implications of the legislation without conducting independent research.
Definitions: The definitions provided within the bill, especially for "border-crossing facility," lack detailed specifications. This could lead to varying interpretations, potentially complicating the practical implementation of the law.
Potential Public Impact
The general public could experience various impacts from this legislation:
Broad Impact
Energy Security: On one hand, by ensuring continuity and reducing uncertainty around energy infrastructure, the bill could enhance energy security and stability. This could lead to a more predictable energy market, which might help prevent sudden fluctuations in energy prices.
Governance and Checks on Presidential Power: By requiring Congressional approval for permit revocations, the bill might be seen as emphasizing checks and balances by restraining unilateral Presidential actions related to cross-border energy agreements.
Stakeholder-Specific Impact
Energy Companies: The bill could be beneficial for energy companies that rely on cross-border permits by providing them with more certainty and protection against sudden changes in policy. This might encourage increased investment within the sector.
Environmental Groups: Conversely, environmental stakeholders may view this bill negatively. It potentially limits the ability of the federal government to halt projects that may pose significant environmental risks or that are no longer aligned with contemporary environmental policies or standards.
Legislative and Executive Branches: The bill might lead to friction between the legislative and executive branches, raising debates over the separation of powers. It could also result in a legislative bottleneck, with Congress having to debate and pass laws for each permit revocation, which could slow down decision-making processes.
In conclusion, H.R. 1587 seeks to impose significant checks on the President's ability to revoke permits related to cross-border energy facilities. While it aims to provide stability and security in energy infrastructure, it also introduces potential challenges related to governmental flexibility, legal clarity, and broader environmental impacts.
Issues
The prohibition on revocation of Presidential permits by the President, except when authorized by an Act of Congress, could create inflexibility in addressing urgent or changing circumstances that may require immediate action. This is specified in Section 2 and may generate legal and political debates over the separation of powers between Congress and the Presidency.
The bill relies heavily on multiple Executive Orders without clarifying their specific contents within the text, which could obscure the full implications and require additional research by policy makers and the public to understand the potential impact fully. This issue arises in Section 2.
There is ambiguity in the definition of what constitutes 'authorization by an Act of Congress.' This ambiguity could lead to legal disputes over interpretation and implementation, as highlighted in Section 2.
The term 'border-crossing facility' is defined, but lacks detailed specification regarding what precise components or operations are considered within the facility at the international boundary. This could lead to interpretation issues in practice, as outlined in Section 2.
The very brief language of Section 1, which serves as the short title, provides no substantial context or detail regarding the Act’s provisions or purpose, leading to potential issues of ambiguity and lack of transparency.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The title of this act is the “Protecting International Pipelines for Energy Security Act.” This is the name given to the legislation, which indicates its focus on safeguarding pipelines that are important for international energy security.
2. Prohibition on revocation of Presidential permits Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section states that the President cannot cancel certain permits for oil, natural gas pipelines, or electric transmission facilities unless Congress approves it. It also defines what a "border-crossing facility" is and what counts as "natural gas" and "oil."