Overview
Title
To affirm that the Farm Credit Administration is the sole and independent regulator of the Farm Credit System.
ELI5 AI
The bill says that a group called the Farm Credit Administration is in charge of keeping an eye on a special bank system, and it asks these banks to collect and share information about small farmers who ask for loans, like their race and gender, but makes sure their private details stay safe.
Summary AI
H. R. 1063, titled the "Farm Credit Administration Independent Authority Act," is a bill that designates the Farm Credit Administration as the sole and independent regulator of the Farm Credit System. The bill mandates that Farm Credit System lenders collect demographic data, such as race, sex, and ethnicity, from small farmer loan applicants and report it annually to the Farm Credit Administration, which will then publish the data while protecting personal identities. It further states that if a rule requiring compliance is invalidated or repealed, Farm Credit System institutions are exempt from adherence to the amendments introduced by this bill. Additionally, the bill amends the Equal Credit Opportunity Act to exclude entities supervised by the Farm Credit Administration from certain provisions.
Published
Keywords AI
Sources
Bill Statistics
Size
Language
Complexity
AnalysisAI
General Summary of the Bill
H.R. 1063, also known as the "Farm Credit Administration Independent Authority Act," affirms the role of the Farm Credit Administration (FCA) as the independent and sole regulator of the Farm Credit System (FCS). The legislation introduces requirements for collecting demographic data from small farmers applying for loans through the FCS. This data, including race, sex, and ethnicity, is to be gathered, maintained, and reported annually by FCS institutions to the FCA, which will then publish this aggregated data, ensuring confidentiality. Additionally, the bill makes adjustments to the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, exempting entities regulated by the FCA from some oversight requirements, and provides conditions for suspension of compliance in certain regulatory circumstances.
Summary of Significant Issues
One of the primary concerns surrounding this bill is the requirement for FCS institutions to collect demographic information, such as race, sex, and ethnicity, from loan applicants, which raises privacy concerns. There might be anxiety regarding how this sensitive information will be protected and what kinds of measures are in place to prevent misuse.
Furthermore, the bill requires that demographic data be publicly available, posing a risk of exposing personal data if adequate privacy safeguards are not implemented. Critics also highlight ambiguities in the bill's language, particularly concerning the voluntary aspect of demographic data disclosure and the limitations on using alternate methods, like visual observation, to record data that applicants choose not to disclose.
Additionally, the bill's exemption of FCA-regulated entities from certain aspects of the Equal Credit Opportunity Act supervision raises questions about the fairness and equality of regulatory oversight. Finally, there is a lack of clarity regarding the enforcement and compliance implications if the rules requiring demographic data collection are repealed.
Broad Public Impact
The bill's intentions to streamline the regulation and enhance the accountability of the Farm Credit System could positively impact transparency and oversight. However, the public might be concerned about privacy issues, particularly regarding the collection and publication of demographic data. If not adequately addressed, such concerns could fuel distrust in financial institutions tasked with safeguarding personal information.
Impact on Specific Stakeholders
Small Farmers: They might benefit from a more structured and transparent loan application process if demographic data helps to identify and address potential biases. However, they might also be wary of sharing personal information, especially without guaranteed safeguards.
Farm Credit System Institutions: These entities will be directly affected by the new data collection and reporting requirements. While the bill may streamline their regulatory obligations under the FCA, it also places additional responsibilities on them to protect sensitive data and ensure accurate reporting.
Farm Credit Administration: The bill reinforces the FCA's regulatory authority, potentially enhancing its capacity to ensure fairness and accountability in the credit system for farmers. The new data collection duties, however, could increase their operational responsibilities and require more resources to manage public disclosures adeptly.
Legislators and Policymakers: For them, balancing the need for oversight and the protection of individual privacy will be a crucial concern. They may need to monitor the implementation of such measures and respond to any unintended consequences effectively.
Overall, H.R. 1063 aims to strengthen the role of the Farm Credit Administration in overseeing the Farm Credit System but raises questions about privacy and data management that require careful consideration and proactive measures to assure all stakeholders.
Issues
The requirement for Farm Credit System institutions to collect demographic data (race, sex, ethnicity) from loan applicants, as detailed in Section 2, raises significant privacy concerns and lacks clarity on how this information will be protected and used. This could lead to public backlash over privacy rights.
The bill mandates that demographic data collected by Farm Credit System institutions be made public annually, which could risk exposing sensitive personal information if privacy preservation methods are not robust. This issue is found in Section 2.
Section 3 introduces an exemption for entities supervised by the Farm Credit Administration from certain supervision under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act. This could lead to concerns about unequal treatment and reduced oversight of exempted entities.
There is ambiguity in how the requirements for collecting and reporting demographic data should be applied, particularly regarding the use of 'visual observation, surname, or any other method' if applicants refuse to disclose their information, as outlined in Section 2. This could lead to inconsistent implementation.
Section 4 does not clearly define the process for re-establishing compliance if a rule is repealed, which may lead to enforcement challenges and a lack of accountability for non-compliance by Farm Credit System institutions.
The bill does not address potential repercussions or enforcement mechanisms for non-compliance with the small farmer loan data collection requirements outlined in Section 4.20, which could result in a lack of accountability among institutions.
Section 4.20 relies on a definition of 'small farmer' from another section without including a summary or explanation, making it difficult for readers unfamiliar with section 4.19 to understand who is included under this category.
Sections
Sections are presented as they are annotated in the original legislative text. Any missing headers, numbers, or non-consecutive order is due to the original text.
1. Short title Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The first section of the bill states that it can be referred to as the “Farm Credit Administration Independent Authority Act.”
2. Farmer loan data collection Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The proposed amendment to the Farm Credit Act of 1971 requires Farm Credit System lenders to ask small farmers to voluntarily disclose demographic information, such as race, sex, and ethnicity, and report this data to the Farm Credit Administration annually. The administration is tasked with collecting and publicly sharing this information, while ensuring no personal details are exposed, and affirming that farmers cannot be compelled to provide this information against their wishes.
4.20. Small farmer loan data collection Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The section establishes that the Farm Credit Administration is the sole regulator of the Farm Credit System and requires lenders to collect and report demographic data about small farmers, such as race, sex, and ethnicity, ensuring that any disclosed information is voluntary and confidential. The information is to be made publicly available by the Farm Credit Administration annually, starting one year after the enactment of the section.
3. Conforming amendment Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
The amendment to Section 704B(h)(1) of the Equal Credit Opportunity Act excludes entities supervised by the Farm Credit Administration from the requirements outlined in that section.
4. Cessation of compliance Read Opens in new tab
Summary AI
If a rule affecting financial institutions is overturned or repealed, then Farm Credit System institutions do not need to follow any related regulations created under the changes introduced by this Act.